This is a review after reading and preparing the two scenarios, but before playtesting. As usual, I will start with a spoiler-free summary and then go into the details, with plenty of spoilers.
TL;DR (no spoilers)
Positives
- The layout and organisation are excellent. Chaosium really knows how to make a scenario book useful at the table.
- Both scenarios start with premises that could lead to something interesting.
- The art is competent and most of it is pleasant to look at.
Negatives
- The scenarios are formulaic and unimaginative. There are plenty of confrontations, but almost no dilemma to solve, hard calls to make, or bets to take.
- Plot is quite constrained. One scenario is an explicit A-to-B-to-C crumb following investigation; the other presents itself as an investigation sandbox but is designed to guarantee its prescribed sequence of events.
- The supposedly unifying theme is a simplistic, barely explored prejudice about wealthy people, passed off as meaningful.
- The Mythos elements and the villains are mostly generic. The book is pulp without the extravagance, horror without much cosmicity, and adventure without much sophistication.
- The illustrations are uninspiring. They fill space.
Overall
I think this is not great. It is professionally produced, easy to navigate, and remarkably lacking what would make me want to run it. I actually prepared to do so, but the more I worked on the scenarios, the less enthusiastic I became. With ten minutes for the first session to start, I decided this was not material I wanted to present to my group, and, in the end, we played a board game instead (and yes, I should probably just have improvised something, but it was a one-shot, and after all the reading I was feeling a bit unispired).
Full review (with spoilers)
Why this matters to me
I first encountered Lovecraft when I was eighteen, through the fifth edition of Call of Cthulhu. It was my first Lovecraftian book, my first horror roleplaying game, and it had an everlasting effect on my imagination. It was eye-opening. I realised that an RPG could be more than fantasy adventures, monsters to fight, treasures to find, or even a good story to play through. It could explore terrifying ideas, moral uncertainty, the fragility of the human condition, and questions about reality that I had never imagined a game could approach with such sophistication. Even better, these questions echoed my own existential anxieties.
I have been playing and running Call of Cthulhu for more than thirty years, and Chaosium has been an extraordinarily important reference throughout that time. And I didn't join the choir of naysayers when seventh edition appeared. It was a bit bloated, yes, and the chase rules were bad, but mechanically I found it a strong game, and I embraced it completely (well, except for the chase rules). I've run the new Masks of Nyarlathotep three times, Berlin: The Wicked City four times, and The Two-Headed Serpent five times.
I was electrified when I first read The Two-Headed Serpent. Yes, that was already some time ago, but it was the same seventh edition, the same Chaosium, and the same Pulp Cthulhu. And I can still be electrified by a horror RPG today. God's Teeth, for Delta Green, and In Thy Blood, for Degenesis, gave me that considerable sense of depth and imaginative discovery. Even The Sutra of the Pale Leaves, whose scenarios I found relatively weak, offers a terrific new metaphysics, full of possibilities involving identity, agency, perception, and the seductions of a perhaps benevolent tyranny.
I'm saying all this because I'm feeling frustrated with some of the latest Chaosium's publications. The books look better and better, the layout improves, and the practical presentation is often excellent. But for some years now I have felt a drift towards simplification, sanitisation, and blandness. The Order of the Stone was a particularly uninspired example. No Time to Scream was okay, with some genuinely good material, but also some of the same weaknesses. This is not some blanket claim that everything Chaosium publishes is terrible; clearly it isn't (I wouldn't call this book terrible, by the way). Nor is it nostalgia for a supposedly perfect past. I am still perfectly capable of being astonished. I just wish Chaosium would give me more reasons to be.
And that brings us to Clockwork & Claws.
The very rich are different from you and me. Apparently, they are also very stupid.
The introduction announces the book's governing theme: wealthy people acquire exotic things, meddle in matters they don't understand, and unleash terrible consequences. We are told that the protagonists' adversaries have been blinded by their own "affluence and arrogance." There is even a Fitzgerald quotation about the rich to set the mood.
Look, I dislike Elon Musk as much as the next guy, but not all magnates are idiots, egotists or meanies. I have no problem whatsoever with a scenario exploring privilege, the arrogance of wealth, or the ability of rich people to impose the consequences of their follies on everybody else. There is plenty to explore there. But that would require the authors to actually explore it.
Here, the idea is stated in such unsophisticated terms that it reminds me of those pub conversations where some tipsy man announces, as if it is a profound statement, to the fascination of the assembled crowd, that behind every great fortune there is a great crime. The book doesn't explicitly claim that all wealthy people are fools, but its facile pairing of affluence and arrogance practically begs that generalisation. It's not a coherent social critique, let alone an interesting one. It's a prejudice masquerading as a theme.
And honestly, if this is the level of sophistication with which you intend to announce the governing theme of a scenario book, perhaps it would be better not to announce one at all.
Of Clockwork & Clay: A to B to C, and then punch the monster
The first scenario begins with a murder at a museum in Boston, and the investigators follow a trail involving a gangster, a clockmaker, a strange artefact, and an eccentric scientist, Dr. Julian Greaves. Greaves believes he is using a lost ancient science to build a machine that will liberate humanity from hunger, disease, and war. In reality, he is being manipulated by mi-go into creating a mechanical vessel for Nyarlathotep, the Tick Tock Man. Meanwhile, Solomon Sydelman, the clockmaker, has built a golem of his own, hoping to protect humanity from an impending catastrophe.
Doesn't that sound as if it could be interesting?
We have a scientist with an almost utopian vision of progress, a mystic who believes salvation must come from a divine creation, and two very different attempts to protect humanity from forces beyond its understanding. We have the whole idea of the golem, with its questions about creation, obedience, autonomy, responsibility, and the relationship between a creator and his creation. We could even explore what humanity should become if older, vastly more advanced civilisations turn out to exist. There is an extraordinary amount of material here.
Unfortunately, almost all of it is thrown out of the window.
What we actually get is a succession of scenes that lead to other scenes. The investigation is functional enough: from the museum to the criminal connection, from there to Sydelman, and eventually to Greaves. The clues are laid out competently, and there are opportunities for confrontations here and there. But when does a clue result in a shocking revelation? Where are the dilemmas? Where are the difficult decisions? What is there for players to do beyond figuring out where the scenario wants them to go next and fighting whoever tries to stop them?
Even worse is the treatment of the Artificers, the scientists working on Greaves' machine. They aren't willing cultists. They are innocent people whose brains have been invaded by mi-go parasites, forced to watch in horror while their bodies obey an alien intelligence. Now there is a genuinely disturbing situation. Do the heroes know what has happened? Can they save these people? What are they willing to do to stop the machine if stopping it means killing its helpless human builders?
The scenario's great contribution to this potential moral nightmare is to suggest that the Artificers can be treated as pulp mooks, who collapse after losing half their hit points. The human tragedy is ignored in favour a small adjustment to the combat mechanics.
Eventually, of course, everybody arrives at the big confrontation, complete with henchmen, mi-go, Artificers, and a monstrous mechanical avatar of Nyarlathotep. There is lots of punching and shooting. And that, more or less, is your adventure.
I have said before that there should be an edict forbidding the attachment of the Nyarlathotep label to any monster desperately in need of some Mythos pedigree. I am not particularly impressed that this machine is supposedly an avatar of Nyarlathotep. What is Nyarlathotepian about it, beyond the name and the frightening statistics? What does the Crawling Chaos bring to this story that could not be provided by a generic supernatural automaton?
And please don't tell me that this is simply what Pulp Cthulhu is supposed to be. The Two-Headed Serpent gives us outrageous pulp adventure, chases, explosions, mad science, and plenty of opportunities to punch monsters. But it also gives us body horror, complex questions of identity and belonging, memory, and genuine dilemmas about the future of humanity in the presence of older and more advanced civilisations. Pulp doesn't have to be this bland, unimaginative, unsophisticated thing.
Of Clockwork & Clay reads like a lazy Saturday morning cartoon from the late eighties: a formulaic plot, a procession of bad guys to defeat, and a big monster at the end.
Wolf Among the Flock: The illusion of a sandbox
The second scenario has a rather appealing starting point. A wealthy family has assembled a private zoo on its estate. But the owners are dead, the zoo is being dismantled, the animals are behaving strangely, and the investigators arrive shortly before a memorial service. There are peculiar members of staff, suspicious circumstances surrounding the deaths, animals that may be spying on the heroes, and even an orangutan able to communicate through sign language. Again, this could have been a wonderful setting for a disturbing investigation.
What lies behind it is considerably less exciting.
Naomi Durney, the owners' daughter, was neglected by her parents, who were more interested in their travels and animal collection than in her. She became lonely and resentful, got involved in the occult, and eventuaklly discovered the Mythos. Her parents return from Africa with an egg of a dark young of Shub-Niggurath. Naomi recognises it, tries to warn them, is dismissed, and murders them in a fit of rage, as one does. The creature hatches, and she decides to nurture it as her parents failed to nurture her because reasons.
I don't expect every Mythos cultist to deliver a philosophical dissertation, but surely Chaosium can do better than this. The Mythos has attracted serious literary and philosophical attention precisely because of the depth of its metaphysical concerns. Yet a remarkable number of recent scenarios seem determined to turn it into a collection of generic monsters and emotionally stunted villains with psychological explanations fit for a cheap television drama.
The dark young itself isn't particularly interesting, either. It eats, grows, and eventually has to be fought. We have a non-descript villain and a non-descript monster. The first is angry with her parents; the second is hungry. Shakespearan villains they are not.
There are also some rather extraordinary contrivances in the investigation. The two estate handymen help dispose of the murdered parents' bodies in a river, but somehow forget which way the river flows, dumping them upstream of the estate. Naturally, the evidence conveniently comes back. Oh well.
But the most irritating aspect of this scenario is its structure. At first glance, it looks like a sandbox investigation. The investigators can explore the estate, talk to people, inspect the animals, and follow different leads. This is precisely the sort of environment in which players should be able to take the initiative and surprise the Keeper.
Except that the scenario has a very specific sequence of events in mind, and it works rather hard to make sure we reach the appointed finale. The Keeper is advised to steer investigators away from Naomi's bedroom if they become suspicious too soon. Elsewhere, the instructions explicitly recommend discouraging them from searching the servants' annex, where they might discover the monster before the scenario is ready for them to do so. This means that if the players insist on investigating the place that their clues point towards, distract them, lock the doors, or move to the predetermined action scene.
And what if the investigators realise that something terrible is about to happen during the memorial and manage to warn or evacuate the guests? Well, the Keeper may still have the eulogy begin before the evacuation is complete, and the scenario proceeds to its monster attack and chase. In other words, the players can investigate, but they had better not investigate effectively, because that might interfere with the authors' carefully prepared climax.
This is lazy scenario design. A real sandbox doesn't require that the players be prevented from solving the mystery early, and a good horror scenario should be able to accommodate the consequences of their discoveries. If the heroes expose Naomi before the memorial, that ought to matter. If they evacuate the guests, that ought to matter. The situation should react to the investigators, not manipulate them until the correct cutscene can play.
There are small absurdities in the finale. Naomi's magical technique allows her to possess an animal at a time, leaving her own body inert. Yet the climactic scene suddenly features dozens of possessed birds attacking a victim, while Naomi is busy with her transformation. Apparently the rules of the scenario are as disposable as the players' decisions when a spectacular set piece needs to happen.
And so we end with another chase, another fight, another monster with a weak motivation and a slim agenda that has to be defeated. A to B to C, only this time with a little more effort spent pretending that we can go wherever we like.
Excellent packaging
There is something particularly frustrating about this: Chaosium is extremely competent at producing books for use at the table. The layout is excellent. The handouts, maps, character summaries, and organisation of the clues are thoughtfully presented. There is a lot of practical experience visible in the way these scenarios are packaged, and the result is more immediately usable than many adventures I have read from other publishers. Credit where credit is due.
But formal competence doesn't excuse a lack of inventiveness, a constraining scenario structure, or the utter lack of sophistication in the underlying themes.
As for the art, it is competent. Some of it is even nice enough to look at. But it has no spark. It doesn't inspire anything. It fills space, and that is about the most damning thing I can say about RPG illustration. Compare it with the artwork in Chaosium's Arkham sourcebook, which I found genuinely inspiring even when the text was difficult to use. Good RPG art doesn't merely show you what is already written on the page; it opens up imaginative possibilities beyond it.
And seriously, this is not how you defeat AI slop, people. In an age when generic, technically adequate images can be produced in industrial quantities, human-made illustrations need to justify their existence through some kind of vision. Simply being professionally competent is no longer enough.
Chaosium is not shy about calling the books they produce art. That raises the bar on my expectations.
I should also clarify what I mean by sanitisation. I'm not complaining that these scenarios don't contain enough blood, murders, or grotesque monsters. They contain all of those things. What has been sanitised is the imagination: the uncomfortable ethical questions, the metaphysical implications, the disturbing possibilities that ought to arise from the material. We are offered horrors that can be defeated in combat, but very little that might actually trouble us after the game is over and again, you may say this is Pulp, and I will raise you The Two-headed Serpent.
Conclusion
Chaosium is supposed to offer something better than what we can find among the contributions of amateurs. Not because independent authors cannot write excellent scenarios, there are dozens of wonderful ones on the Miskatonic Repository, but because an official publisher with Chaosium's history, resources, and experience should be setting a standard.
This isn't it.
I know that a sufficiently inventive Keeper can turn almost anything into an entertaining evening. I could flesh out these villains, introduce real dilemmas, loosen the rails, and make something of the ideas that the authors have left unexplored. But why should I have to do all the hard work? What, exactly, am I paying for?
I prepared these adventures and realised that I didn't want to run them. We played a board game instead. That tells you rather more about my reaction than any numerical rating could.
I would much rather be enthusiastic. I have loved Call of Cthulhu for most of my life, and I still want Chaosium to astonish me as it has done before. Clockwork & Claws is a reminder that excellent layout, competent art, and a famous logo do not make a good scenario book. You need imagination. You need something worth exploring. And, above all, you need to trust the players to do more than follow instructions and punch the monster.
Here, sadly, there is very little of any of that.

Comments
Post a Comment